1997| QB | John Elway, Athenian Woodchucks |
| RB | Barry Sanders, Mayberry Fifes |
| RB | Terrell Davis, Sin City Grifters |
| WR | Cris Carter, West Coast Mennonites |
| WR | Herman Moore, Sin City Grifters |
| WR | Rob Moore, Bakersfield B'Nai B'Rith |
| TE | Shannon Sharpe, Bakersfield B'Nai B'Rith |
| Defense | Steelers, Iron City Blitzers |
| PK | Morton Andersen, Iron City Blitzers |
| 1998| QB | Steve Young, Bakersfield Circus Bears |
| RB | Terrell Davis, Sin City Grifters |
| RB | Jamal Anderson, Sin City Grifters |
| WR | Randy Moss, Boston Slammin' Lagers |
| WR | Antonio Freeman, Toledo Neaderthal |
| WR | Ed McCaffrey, Athenian Woodchucks |
| TE | Shannon Sharpe, Bakersfield Circus Bears |
| Defense | Seahawks, Sin City Grifters |
| PK | Gary Anderson, Waterworld Wombats |
|
1999| QB | Kurt Warner, Waterworld Wombats |
| RB | Edgerrin James, Honolulu Headbangers |
| RB | Marshall Faulk, Bakersfield Cirus Bears |
| WR | Marvin Harrison, Waterworld Wombats |
| WR | Cris Carter, West Coast Mennonites |
| WR | Isaac Bruce, Honolulu Headbangers |
| TE | Wesley Walls, Honolulu Headbangers |
| Defense | Jaguars, Honolulu Headbangers |
| PK | Mike Hollis, Toledo Neanderthal |
|
2000 1st Team| QB | Brian Griese, Mayberry Fifes |
| RB | Marshall Faulk, Bakersfield Cirus Bears |
| RB | Edgerrin James, West Coast Mennonites |
| WR | Terrell Owens, Bakersfield Circus Bears |
| WR | Marvin Harrison, Moose River Mounties |
| WR | Rod Smith, Boston Lagers |
| TE | Tony Gonzalez, West Coast Mennonites |
| Defense | Ravens, Toledo Neanderthal |
| PK | Matt Stover, East Coast Killah Bees |
2000 2nd Team| QB | Peyton Manning, Boston Lagers |
| RB | Ricky Williams, Moose River Mounties |
| RB | Robert Smith, Bakersfield Circus Bears |
| WR | Issac Bruce, Boston Lagers |
| WR | Randy Moss, East Coast Killah Bees |
| WR | Ed McCaffrey, Mayberry Fifes |
| TE | Shannon Sharpe, Bakersfield Circus Bears |
| Defense | Buccaneers, Mayberry Fifes |
| PK | Martin Gramatica, West Virginia Woolfs |
|
2001 1st Team| QB | Kurt Warner, Moose River Mounties |
| RB | Marshall Faulk, Bakersfield Cirus Bears |
| RB | Ahman Green, West Virginia Woolfs |
| WR | Terrell Owens, Boston Lagers |
| WR | Marvin Harrison, Moose River Mounties |
| WR | Rod Smith, West Virginia Woolfs |
| TE | Tony Gonzalez, West Coast Mennonites |
| Defense | Eagles, Athenian Woodchucks |
| PK | Jason Elam, Athenian Woodchucks |
2001 2nd Team| QB | Jeff Garcia, Toledo Neanderthal |
| RB | Curtis Martin, Toledo Neanderthal |
| RB | Priest Holmes, Moose River Mounties |
| WR | David Boston, West Virginia Woolfs |
| WR | Jimmy Smith, West Coast Mennonites |
| WR | Tim Brown, Sin City Grifters |
| TE | Frank Wychek, Athenian Woodchucks |
| Defense | Steelers, West Coast Mennonites |
| PK | John Carney, East Coast Killah Bees |
|
2002 1st Team| QB | Rich Gannon, Pueblo Prairiedogs |
| RB | Priest Holmes, Columbus Shortbus |
| RB | LaDainian Tomlinson, West Coast Mennonites |
| WR | Marvin Harrison, Toledo Neanderthal |
| WR | Hines Ward, Pueblo Prairiedogs |
| WR | Terrell Owens, Pueblo Prairiedogs |
| TE | Tony Gonzalez, East Coast Killah Bees |
| Defense | Buccaneers, East Coast Killah Bees |
| PK | Ryan Longwell, Columbus Shortbus |
2002 2nd Team| QB | Peyton Manning, Bakersfield Circus Bears |
| RB | Marshall Faulk, Bakersfield Circus Bears |
| RB | Ricky Williams, East Coast Killah Bees |
| WR | Eric Moulds, West Coast Mennonites |
| WR | Peerless Price, Sin City Grifters |
| WR | Jerry Rice, Toledo Neanderthal |
| TE | Bubba Franks, Sin City Grifters |
| Defense | Packers, Sin City Grifters |
| PK | Martin Gramatica, Mayberry Fifes |
|
2003 1st Team| QB | Peyton Manning, Bakersfield Cirus Bears |
| RB | Priest Holmes, Athenian Woodchucks |
| RB | Ahman Green, West Virginia Woolfs |
| WR | Torry Holt, Sin City Grifters |
| WR | Randy Moss, Moose River Mounties |
| WR | Chad Johnson, Sin City Grifters |
| TE | Tony Gonzalez, Boston Lagers |
| Defense | Buccaneers, West Coast Mennonites |
| PK | Jeff Wilkins, Sin City Grifters |
2003 2nd Team| QB | Daunte Culpepper, Toledo Neanderthal |
| RB | LaDainian Tomlinson, West Coast Mennonites |
| RB | Deuce McAllister, Sin City Grifters |
| WR | Santana Moss, Sin City Grifters |
| WR | Hines Ward, Mayberry Fifes |
| WR | Marvin Harrison, West Virginia Woolfs |
| TE | Shannon Sharpe, Bakersfield Circus Bears |
| Defense | Ravens, Sin City Grifters |
| PK | Mike Vanderjagt, West Virginia Woolfs |
|
2004 1st Team| QB | Peyton Manning, Bakersfield Cirus Bears |
| RB | Priest Holmes, Athenian Woodchucks |
| RB | LaDainian Tomlinson, Moose River Mounties |
| WR | Terrell Owens, Seaside Squid |
| WR | Joe Horn, Seaside Squid |
| WR | Javon Walker, West Virginia Woolfs |
| TE | Antonio Gates, West Virginia Woolfs |
| Defense | Patriots, Moose River Mounties |
| PK | Adam Vinatieri, West Virginia Woolfs |
2004 2nd Team| QB | Daunte Culpepper, Toledo Neanderthal |
| RB | Shaun Alexander, West Virginia Woolfs |
| RB | Curtis Martin, Athenian Woodchucks |
| WR | Marvin Harrison, Athenian Woodchucks |
| WR | Chad Johnson, Toledo Neanderthal |
| WR | Torry Holt, Beaver State Woodies |
| TE | Tony Gonzalez, Moose River Mounties |
| Defense | Bills, West Virginia Woolfs |
| PK | David Akers, Sin City Grifters |
|
2005 1st Team| QB | Carson Palmer, West Virginia Woolfs |
| RB | LaDainian Tomlinson, West Coast Mennonites |
| RB | Shaun Alexander, West Virginia Woolfs |
| WR | Steve Smith, Mayberry Fifes |
| WR | Larry Fitzgerald, Moose River Mounties |
| WR | Chad Johnson, Sin City Grifters |
| TE | Antonio Gates, Sin City Grifters |
| Defense | Colts, Seaside Squid |
| PK | Neil Rackers, Moose River Mounties |
2005 2nd Team| QB | Peyton Manning, Bakersfield Circus Bears |
| RB | Edgerrin James, Seaside Squid |
| RB | Lamont Jordan, Moose River Mounties |
| WR | Torry Holt, Caribbean Yachtsmen |
| WR | Anquan Boldin, Bakersfield Circus Bears |
| WR | Joey Galloway, Toledo Neanderthal |
| TE | Alge Crumpler, Seaside Squid |
| Defense | Bears, Moose River Mounties |
| PK | Shayne Graham, Mayberry Fifes |
|
2006 1st Team| QB | Drew Brees, Sin City Grifters |
| RB | LaDainian Tomlinson, West Coast Mennonites |
| RB | Brian Westbrook, Athenian Woodchucks |
| WR | Steve Smith, West Coast Mennonites |
| WR | Chad Jackson, Sin City Grifters |
| WR | Darrell Walker, Springfield Atoms |
| TE | Tony Gonzalez, Athenian Woodchucks |
| Defense | Bears, Toledo Neanderthal |
| PK | Jeff Wilkins, West Coast Mennonites |
2006 2nd Team| QB | Peyton Manning, Bakersfield Circus Bears |
| RB | Larry Johnson, West Coast Mennonites |
| RB | Steven Jackson, Springfield Atoms |
| WR | Andre Johnson, Bakersfield Circus Bears |
| WR | T.J. Houshmandzadeh, Moose River Mounties |
| WR | Terrell Owens, West Virginia Woolfs |
| TE | Antonio Gates, Sin City Grifters |
| Defense | Chargers, Mayberry Fifes |
| PK | Adam Vinatieri, Sin City Grifters |
|
|
|
